The Panama-Pacific International Exposition

PPIE and the Phonograph, San Francisco, 1915

 

By Doug Boilesen 2023

There were five phonograph companies which exhibited machines at the 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition (PPIE) held in San Francisco: The Victor Talking Machine Co., the Columbia Graphophone Co., the Sonora Phonograph Corp., the Cheney Talking Machine Co., and Gabel's Automatic Entertainer.

Edison did not have an exhibit at PPIE, however, there was an "Edison Day" on October 21 and Christine Miller appeared at the Panama-Pacific Exposition and sang with Edison's Diamond Disc re-creation as part of her Transcontinental Tone-Test Tour.

The PPIE was a celebration of the completion of the Panama Canal and there was a large concession at the exposition featuring a working diorama of the Panama Canal. That Panama Canal Zone exhibit is featured on this page since it used a "telephone-phonographic system" which combined telephone system and sixty phonographs to play Edison Amberol Records and provide a unique guided tour.

This gallery has four sections:

Phonographs Exhibited at the PPIE

"Edison Day" at the PPIE

"The Panama Canal Exhibit"

The Edison Blue Amberol Records for the Panama Canal Tour

Edison Films made for New York State's Exhibition

 

Souvenir booklet for Panama-Pacific Exposition. Published by Pacific Novelty Co., 1915. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

 

Phonographs at The Panama-Pacific International Exhibition

The Columbia Graphophone Company (listed also in Official PPIE Catalogue of Exhibitors as The American Graphophone Co. with same NY address).

 

The Talking Machine World, April 15, 1915.

 

The Talking Machine World, March 15, 1915, p. 19.

 

Exhibit of the Columbia Graphophone Company. "The Blue Book, A Comprehensive Official Souvenir View Book Illustrating the Panama-Pacific International Exposition at San Francisco 1915," Robert A. Reid, View Books, San Francisco, 1915 , p. 99.

 

Columbia Graphophone Company's "Dictaphone" was identified as the official Dictation Machine of the PPIE Company:

Liberal Arts Official Catalog of Exhibitors Panama Pacific Exposition, Group 29 (ibid. p. 18).

 

Mortimer D. Easton, Manager of the Columbia Booth and newly elected director and a member of the executive committee of the Columbia Co., shown dictating on Columbia Dictaphone, The Talking Machine World, April 1915.

 

The Talking Machine World, March 15, 1915

 

LISTEN to The Star Spangled Banner sung by Margaret Woodrow Wilson, Columbia 10" A1685 double-sided disc (with medley of national airs on reverse side). Recorded on January 22, 1915 and promoted by Columbia's as a Souvenir Record at the PPIE with Wilson's entire royalty (25¢ per record) donated to the American Red Cross to aid European war suffers. (Source: David Giovannoni Collection).

 

The Victor Talking Machine Co., "The Handsome Victor Temple."

"The Victor Temple, as the exhibit of the Victor Talking Machine Co. is officially known, is artistically built and beautifully furnished, and from the advantageous location under the dome in the center of the building has already proved itself a center of interest. The temple is of old Roman Doric architecture and includes a drawing room with miniature stage, reception room, office and rest rooms, also a record room supplied with 7,000 records, domestic and foreign, which will be used in daily concerts...Two beautiful Victrolas, hand-painted on a dull-gold finish, are placed on the stage, and many other handsome instruments are included in the display." The Talking Machine World, March 15, 1915, p. 19.

 

 

The Talking Machine World, March 15, 1915

 

Liberal Arts Palace where inside Victor's Temple of Music was located, postcard, 1915.

 

The Talking Machine World, April 15, 1915.

 

Unico ad for Victor's Temple Music as an example of Unico Service, The Talking Machine World, July 15, 1915.

Record listening booths for baby boomers were still common in record and department stores, however, CDs and iPods and Spotify have since removed that 'experience' for the new music listening generations. High-end listening rooms for sound systems are probably the best remaining examples of that sound shopping experience. See Phonographia's Record Listening Booths for more examples from the era that introduced the phonograph and its record demonstration rooms. See Shopping for a Phonograph for early advertising examples of encouraging consumers to visit a phonograph dealer and listen for themselves.

 

The Talking Machine World, July 15, 1915.

 

Victor Souvenir Post Card with Victor Temple of Music (PM-0298).

 

 

Sonora Phonograph Co.'s "Excellent Exhibit."

"The Sonora Phonograph Co., of this city, occupied the booth across Fourth street from the Columbia exhibit, with a comprehensive showing of Sonora phonographs. This booth...is well equipped for demonstration purposes, there being large open space for a general display, besides sound-proof rooms. The decorations of the booth are carried out effectively in old rose and a blue gray, while a touch of gold is given by gilt bells, which form a prominent feature of the decoration. These bear the words "Clear as a Bell," the trade-mark of Sonora products. A large bell stands in the center of the terrace, and a number of small ones surmount the balustrade at regular intervals." (Ibid. p. 19).

 

The Talking Machine World, April 15, 1915.

 

The Talking Machine World, July 15, 1915.

 

The Talking Machine World, September 15, 1915.

 

After Sonora's 1915 "Award" at the Panama-Pacific Exposition the logo inside their phonograph lids was updated.

 

According to this and other advertisements Sonora had received an award for "perfect score for Tone Quality" at PPIE, magazine ad (5.75" x 8.25"), 1915. What a "perfect score" meant is unclear and awards like this for Edison were now seemingly irrelevant. Instead, Edison's ads would make the case that Christine Miller's Edison Day performance at the PPIE where she sang with Edison's Diamond Disc re-creation of her own voice and no one could tell the difference was indisputable evidence that "Edison's new invention is in a class by itself."

The Edison Phonograph Monthly, November 1915

 

For examples of Sonora's phonograph advertisements after 1915 see Phonographia's Sonora - "Clear as a Bell."

 

Cheney Talking Machine Co.'s Exhibit.

"A space 30 by 60 feet between the Victor and Columbia displays has been taken by the Cheney Talking Machine Co., which is making its advent in the Pacific Coast territory. This booth is entirely enclosed. Half of the space is being utilized for a concert hall and the remainder for office, rest room, record room etc." (Ibid. p. 19).

 

 

The Talking Machine World, April 15, 1915.

 

Gabel's Automatic Entertainer - "New "Automatic Entertainer" Shown."

"An instrument known as Gabel's Automatic Entertainer, which is being demonstrated by the Golden Gate Music Co., of San Francisco, in the Palace of Liberal Arts, has been the subject of much curiosity, as this is the first time it has ever been shown at an exposition. It plays talking machine records and will play for hours without stopping, changing its own records and needles automatically." (Ibid. p. 19).

 

Gabel Entertainers Awarded Exposition Gold Medal for automatic talking machines and the official award ribbon.

 

The Talking Machine World, September 15, 1915.

 

Edison Day at the Panama-Pacific International Exhibition - October 21, 1915

 

Edison did not have a phonograph exhibit at the PPIE but he was honored by the officials of the Panama-Pacific Exposition on "Edison Day." The Talking Machine World described Edison Day as "one of the most remarkable days in the entire history of the exposition:

...if he should contribute nothing further to the talking machine industry in the way of inventive ideas, his name would still be an asset of incomparable value. The name of Edison possesses a drawing power that is beyond power of estimate."

 

The Talking Machine World, November 15, 1915.

 

Edison's trade magazine, The Edison Phonograph Monthly, also naturally described the details of the Transcontinental phone call made on "Edison Day," October 21, 1915:

"This call involved Mr. Hutchison in New Jersey saying "Hello, Mr. Edison." Mr. Edison's voice was promptly and distinctly heard in response. Mr. Edison's voice was promptly and distinctly heard in response. Then a Diamond Disc Record (a formal address by Mr. Hutchison to Mr. Edison), was placed on a Diamond Disc Phonograph on the platform. From time to time Dr. Hutchison announced to the audience, "Mr. Edison is hearing it perfectly." This information was conveyed by telegraph from a transcontinental telegraph line, in use for the purpose, as well as a transcontinental telephone wire." (The Edison Phonograph Monthly, November 1915.)

 

LISTEN to this Special Limited Edition Edison Disc Record of the Transcontinental Phone call made on October 21, 1915 from the Edison Laboratory in Orange, New Jersey to Mr. Edison in San Francisco. (Note: The Edison Disc recording (below) are courtesy of David Giovannoni Collection at the Library of Congress and i78s.org.)

 

 

The Edison Phonograph Monthly, November 1915.

 

After the recorded "formal address" of Mr. Hutchison was completed Edison responded:

I heard the record of Hutch's talk very plainly. I should now like to hear a musical record. If you have one handy I wish you would play Anna Case's bird song. This was done, and word was received back by telegraph during its playing: "Mr. Edison is hearing it perfectly." Then Mr. Edison put the same selection on his Diamond Disc at San Francisco, in order that guests at the Laboratory might hear as he had heard. The tones were sweet and clear and perfectly audible, without any strain to hear them; the high notes and trills being exactly as clear as if heard over a short distance 'phone, although not quite so loud. (Ibid. EPM, p. 10).

 

 

Anna Case

Anna Case's' "bird song" requested by Edison was the Edison Diamond Disc Record "Charmant Oiseau" ("Thou Brilliant Bird"). Playing this record was said to demonstrate that "music from the Edison Diamond Disc Phonograph can be carried from ocean to ocean" and be perfectly heard. (3)

 

LISTEN To Anna Case singing "Charmant oiseau," Record No. 82078. Matrix 2460, Recorded 1913-09-16 (Courtesy: Internet Archive and University of California Santa Barbara).

 

Thomas Edison at the Exposition

Thomas Edison and Henry Ford at Western Union exhibit in the Liberal Arts Palace. Cardinell-Vincent Company, Photographer. 1915. Courtesy of the University of California, Davis. (6)

 

Luther Burbank, Thomas Edison, and Henry Ford at the Palace of Machinery (Source: Screenshot from PPIE film - Julius S. Rodman Associates, Documentary Film Division, Tiburon, CA, KPIX TV)

Thomas Edison and Teddy Roosevelt in automobile at the fair. (Source: Ibid).

 

 

Christine Miller at the Exposition

Another event on "Edison Day" which promoted the Edison Diamond Disc Phonograph was Christine Miller's performance at the PPIE where she sang with Edison's Diamond Disc re-creation of her own voice to demonstrate that Edison had achieved his ambition actually to re-create music so perfectly that the re-creation cannot be distinguished from the original."

 

The Edison Phonograph Monthly, November 1915.

 

The Boston Sunday Herald reported the following details about Christine Miller's Tone-Test performed on October 21, 1915 in their November 21, 1915 edition:

"The first tone-test was given at the Panama Pacific exposition on October 21, Edison Day, as it was called....On that day Miss Christine Miller consented to prove to Mr. Edison just what perfection he had attained in reproducing the human voice. Before a vast crowd of visitors from all corners of the globe Miss Miller sang her first duet with herself. So astounding was the initial performance, so identical was her voice with its laboratory reproduction, that even Edison admitted that he had invented something far beyond his ambition." (5)

 

Christine Miller

 

Miller and other Edison tone-test artists would be heavily promoted during the next decade as they travelled and performed in listening rooms, rented halls, and auditoriums throughout the country. Countless newspaper ads highlighted the popularity of these comparison tests and the difficulty listeners had in telling the difference between the 'live' and the recorded sounds.

"Not one could distinguish the living and breathing Christine Miller's voice from Edison's laboratory Re-Creation of that self same voice...May we prove it to you?"

By 1920 Edison's tone-tests had been performed more than four-thousand times. They would continue until 1925.

 

"The Edison Diamond Disc: The Re-Creation (not reproduction) of all forms of music." The Talking Machine World, February 1916.

 

For more on Edison's Re-Creation of voices and Edison's tone-tests visit Phonographia's gallery Edison Tone Tests.

For more details about "Edison Day," see "On this Day - October 21 - Edison Day " by PPIE-100.

 

 

The "Panama Canal" Exhibit

The Panama Canal Zone was near the Fillmore Street entrance of the fair and was almost five acres in size. It was advertised as the "largest reproduction of any subject ever created." This working diorama of the Panama Canal used a moving platform where its visitors sat and could look down at the miniaturized Canal Zone. A system combining telephones and sixty Edison Phonographs and respective Blue Amberol records synchronized with the visitor's changing views of the diorama 20 feet below provided the audio for the unique guided tour.

The following is an excerpt from Allen Koenigsberg's article “Step Right Up! Edison’s Blue Amberol Tour of the Panama Canal," (Koenigsberg, Allen, "The Sound Box," December 2007).

"On the moving platforms, there are 1200 opera chairs, each equipped with a duplex telephone receiver; that is, a receiver for each car attached to an adjustable handle so that the spectator can hold it to his ears without placing his arms in an unnatural or uncomfortable position. Through these receivers, the spectators get a continual (and gradually updated) lecture as the trip is made around the ‘miniaturized’ Canal Zone. The system by which this lecture is delivered was invented and perfected especially for this purpose and consists of a novel combination of phonograph and telephones. This in itself marks a new era in sound reproduction. Sixty phonographs, located in a nearby room deliver the lecture into telephone transmitters, which in turn transmit it (in segments) through a series of wires, rails, and various devices to the telephone receivers attached to the seats on the platform, as each makes its circuit." (Koenigsberg, Ibid. p. 5.)

 

 

"THE PANAMA CANAL" and "SCENES ON THE PANAMA CANAL" show the main building and some features of the diorama of the Panama Canal as seen in "The Blue Book, A Comprehensive Official Souvenir View Book Illustrating the Panama-Pacific International Exposition at San Francisco 1915", Robert A. Reid, View Books, San Francisco, 1915 , p. 308.

 

Scenes on the Panama Canal. (Ibid. p. 309).

 

"Official Opening of the Panama-Pacific International Exposition, San Francisco, 1915" is a film of the Panama-Pacific International Exposition made by the Exposition Players Company. Footage includes visitors going into the Panama Canal exhibit, taking their seats and then viewing the diorama scenes and the mechanically operated features of the Canal Zone. (Footage starts at 41:36). (Source material provided by Bancroft Library. Preserved and made available online by California Revealed.)

A 1932 Version of the 16mm film was later released titled "Phantom City: A Retrospect of the Panama-Pacific International Exposition of 1915" by Long (S.C.) Productions. (Source: the Frank Vail Collection.)

 

Seated visitors viewing the 'Panama Canal Zone" from their moving chairs with a receiver attached to an adjustable handle so that the spectator can hold it to his ears without placing his arms in an unnatural or uncomfortable position." (Koenigsberg, ibid. p. 5.) (Above screenshot from 1932 film at 7:45.)

 

Visitors observing from 20 feet above the Panama Canal Zone diorama. (Screenshot at 7:50 of film.)

 

Still from the1915 film looking down at the canal entrance. (Screenshot at 42:35 of film.)

 

Another view for the spectators as seen in the 1932 movie. (Screenshot at 7:41 of film.)

 

Cover for "The Panama Canal at San Francisco 1915" booklet published by Panama Canal Exhibition Co. (Source: "The Last Great World's Fair." JB-TPC Booklets/Brochures from The Jamieson Collection.)

 

 

 

The Edison Blue Amberol Records for the Panama Canal Tour

The Edison Records used at the Panama Canal Concession played, on average, 3300 times per week and were said to have been replaced on an average of every six weeks. Edison's trade magazine The Edison Phonograph Monthly reminded its dealers that this durability of Blue Amerbols should be a strong selling point.

 

The Edison Phonograph Monthly, June 1915.

 

Blue Amberol Record for Panama Canal Zone G, No. 20, 21 and 22

See “Step Right Up! Edison’s Blue Amberol Tour of the Panama Canal," (Koenigsberg, Allen, "The Sound Box," December 2007, p. 7) for a photograph of the rim of "one of 15 such cylinders" used for the "23 minute circuit" tour and a transcription of the Panama Exhibit Co.'s telephone-phonographic 'lecture" on a Blue Amberol Record for Zone G, No. 20, 21 and 22 (Field Markers) of the tour -- The Operation of the Panama Canal, as explained by Harry Humphrey on a ‘2-Minute-style’ Edison Blue Amberol Cylinder.

Transcription of Two-Minute-Style "Panama Canal Zone G" Blue Amberol Cylinder, The Antique Phonograph Monthly, May 1987, p., 6 (the original article where the retelling of this story began, courtesy Allen Koenigsberg).

 

Zone G Mark No. 20: The City of Colon, looking toward Gatun Locks and Limon Bay. ("The Blue Book," Ibid. p. 309.)

 

 

Blue Amberol Record for Panama Canal Zone D, No. 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9

The Operation of the Panama Canal, as explained by Harry Humphrey for Zone D, No. 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9 (Field Markers) on a '2-Minute-style' Edison Blue Amberol Cylinder.

LISTEN to The Operation of the Panama Canal Zone D, as explained by Harry Humphrey. [Download option to Listen] - (Record courtesy of Rod Pickett.)

The following is its transcription with the diorama's tour position Mark Numbers noted by narrator.

"Zone D. Number 4 Mark Miraflores Lock. Here vessels are lifted 55 feet in two stages, from sea level to the level of Miraflores Lake shown at 5. Crossing this lake, a distance of a mile and a half, the vessels come to Number 6, the Pedro Miguel Lock, where they are lifted 30 feet to the famous Culebra Cut, the level there being 85 feet above sea level the highest level reached by a vessel in crossing the Isthmus.

Number 7 marks the center of the Culebra Cut, which during the construction period was the most famous and interesting part of the canal. It is nine miles long and has an average depth of 120 feet; and at Gold Hill, Number 8, a maximum average depth of 375 feet, more than 100 million cubic yards of material was removed from this cut, approximately half the excavation of the entire canal.

Enormous slides developed along the banks of this cut and one of the largest, the Cucaracha Slide, is shown at 9. More about this great cut later."

 

Zone D Mark Number 4

Zone D Mark Number 4: "The Miraflores and Pedro Miguel Locks, "Scenes on the Panama Canal, ("The Blue Book," ibid. p. 309).

 

Construction at the Cucaracha slide, Panama Canal (between 1910 and 1914) (Source: Library of Congress).

Detroit Publishing Co., Copyright Claimant, and Publisher Detroit Publishing Co. Famous Cucaracha slide, Panama Canal. Panama Panama Canal, None. [between 1910 and 1914] Photograph. https://www.loc.gov/item/2016814015/.

 

"Exposition March San Francisco 1915" by Leo Friedman, Frank K.Root & Co., Chicago New York 1915 (Courtesy Jamieson Collection, JC-SEM).

 

LISTEN to "Panama Exposition March" (Chas. A. Prince) Played by Prince's Band, Columbia 10" Record No. A1195 (Courtesy David Giovannoni Collection and i78s.org).

 

 

"Panama Canal March," by Will Wood. Published by Will Wood, New York, 1913 (Source: Lester S. Levy Sheet Music Collection, Johns Hopkins).

 

 

LISTEN to "Through the Panama Canal" (Von der Mehden) Descriptive played by Prince's Band, Columbia 10" Record No. A1528 (Courtesy David Giovannoni Collection and i78s.org).

 

 

"Panama Pacific Exposition Grand March" by L.J. Meyerholtz. "Dedicated to the Panama Exposition." Published by H.R. McClure Company, Sidney, Ohio, 1912 (Source: Lester S. Levy Sheet Music Collection, Johns Hopkins).

 

"In San Francisco the Fair Will Be Best," Words by Sam Harrison. Music by A.J. Bloom. Publisher Southwest Music Publishing Co., 851 Washington St., Oakland, CA, 1910 (Source: Lester S. Levy Sheet Music Collection, Johns Hopkins).

 

"San Francisco The World's Fair Town," Words by Andy Graves. Music by Eddie Jewell. Publisher Benj. Curtaz & Sons, 115 Kearney St., San Francisco, 1912 (Source: Lester S. Levy Sheet Music Collection, Johns Hopkins).

 

 

"San-Fran-Pan-American March & Two-Step" by Joel P. Corin, Geo. W. Meyer music Co., New York, 1915 (Courtesy Jamieson Collection, JC-SFP).

 

LISTEN to "San Francisco (At that San-Fran-Pan-American Fair" sung by Arthur Fields, Columbia Record No. A1699, Recorded January 26, 1915 (Courtesy of David Giovannoni Collection).

 

LISTEN to "Dear Old Pal of Mine" (Rice) Sung by Charles Hackett, Columbia Record No. 79196, Recorded June 17, 1920 (DAHR). The label is an example of how Columbia Records leveraged an award at PPIE (not for this recorrd) but for "Highest Awards" at Panama-Pacific Exhibition. Recording courtesy of Internet Archive.

(Record Label courtesy Jamieson Collection, JC-RSS).

 

 

LISTEN to "1915 San Francisco (March Song)" Sung by Henry Burr and Albert Campbell, Record No. A1623 Recorded Oct 27, 1914 New York (Courtesy DAHR)

 

WATCH 1915 San Francisco March sung by Henry Burr and Albert Campbell, Columbia Record 1914 - YouTube video created by abendstunde49 (2013).

 

 

WATCH PBS AMERICAN EXPERIENCE "The Panama Canal." - The Trailer :30 (Courtesy of PBS)

On August 15, 1914, the Panama Canal opened connecting the world's two largest oceans and signaling America's emergence as a global superpower. The story of the canal features a cast of colorful characters ranging from an indomitable president to visionary engineers to tens of thousands of workers from around the world, rigidly segregated by race.

 

Edison Films made for New York State's PPIE Exhibition

"The Kinetogram," February 1915, p. 5 (The HathiTrust)

 

 

 

Special thanks to Allen Koenigsberg, David Giovannoni, the Bancroft Library, the Lester Levy Sheet Music Collection, the University of California-Davis, the Internet Archive, The HathiTrust, Library of Congress, Rod Pickett and John Jamieson.

See The Jamieson Collection for more examples of PPIE ephemera and collectibles including sheet music and records.

 

 

 

Phonographia